Bioedge
Friday, September 21, 2018

If you are having trouble viewing this email, click here.


Last year Sydney journalist Miranda Devine interviewed Australia’s first out-of-the-closet transsexual, Carlotta, a cabaret performer and TV actor. Carlotta had what is now called “gender-affirming” surgery in the early 1970s and built a career in show biz. Her advice to teenagers who want to transition to the opposite sex: “Don’t give the child hormones. Wait till 18. You shouldn’t fool around with the body until you’re mature.”

This seems common sense. However, as an article in JAMA Pediatrics (see below) reports, girls as young as 13 are receiving mastectomies to treat their gender dysphoria. Two years later (ie, when they’re 15) the transteens are supposedly as happy as Larry with their “top job”.

This doesn’t seem common sense. How can a girl of 13 give truly informed consent to a life-changing operation which removes both of her breasts? As a growing number of “detransitioners” bear witness, this is crazy. “I’m a real-live 22-year-old woman with a scarred chest and a broken voice and a 5 o’clock shadow because I couldn’t face the idea of growing up to be a woman,” says Carla in a YouTube video.

The risk of turning a young girl’s life into a misery is just too great to allow teen mastectomies before adulthood. In fact, it’s hard to describe it as anything other than child abuse by her physicians and psychologists. What do you think?



Michael Cook
Editor
BioEdge
  Comment on BioedgeFind Us on FacebookFollow us on Twitter

NEWS THIS WEEK

Where does palliative sedation become euthanasia?
by Michael Cook | Sep 21, 2018
Distinguishing types of sedation helps to clarify issues

Would you pay to participate in a clinical trial?
by Michael Cook | Sep 21, 2018
A novel model for funding should be considered, say New Zealand bioethicists

Should all newborns receive genome sequencing?
by Michael Cook | Sep 21, 2018
No, says a special report from The Hastings Center

Another step closer to legal abortion in Ireland
by Michael Cook | Sep 21, 2018
President has signed legislation into law

13-year-olds given mastectomies at California clinic
by Michael Cook | Sep 15, 2018
The girls have no regrets, transgender counsellors

British grandparents use dead son’s sperm to create child
by Michael Cook | Sep 15, 2018
Allegations of criminal behaviour by urologist

Amend law to allow organ donor euthanasia, say Canadian doctors
by Michael Cook | Sep 15, 2018
It has significant advantages for transplant patients

Most Quebec doctors in survey favour euthanasia for demented patients
by Michael Cook | Sep 15, 2018
However, it’s against the law at the moment

One drug manufacturer’s moral universe
by Michael Cook | Sep 15, 2018
Sell for the highest possible price

Charlie Gard amendment introduced into British parliament
by Xavier Symons | Sep 15, 2018
The amendment would allow mediation before disputes go to court.

“Baby factories” in the Ukraine exposed
by Xavier Symons | Sep 15, 2018
Surrogates have been mistreated by the country's largest surrogacy company.

Alcor sued for freezing man’s head but not his body
by Xavier Symons | Sep 15, 2018
The man's body was cremated and sent to his family.

When is it ethical to dig up the dead?
by Xavier Symons | Sep 15, 2018
Archaeologists are not the only ones asking the question
IN DEPTH THIS WEEK
BioEdge
Suite 12A, Level 2 | 5 George St | North Strathfield NSW 2137 | Australia
Phone: +61 2 8005 8605
Mobile: 0422-691-615
Email: michael@bioedge.org