The death of a young Australian wife and mother raises the question of whether healthcare workers should always comply with the wishes of their patients.
A coronial inquiry is investigating the death in 2014 of a 28-year-old Adelaide woman, Claudia La Bella. It turns out that she was spending A$500 a week on laxatives, sometimes consuming as many as 800 tablets a day.
Mrs La Bella was a complicated woman. Skeletal and weak from the laxatives, she concocted a story for her family and friends that she was suffering from ovarian cancer. She had also embezzled $374,000 from her employer over five years, which no doubt created a great deal of tension.
However, a psychiatrist declared that it was incomprehensible that the staff at a local pharmacy would order 25 to 30 boxes of Dulcolax for her every week, each containing 200 laxative tablets.
"I still cannot comprehend how they morally and ethically sold someone up to $500 a week worth of laxatives," Dr Maria Naso said. "Just because they are not a regulated item does not mean we can forfeit our moral and ethical responsibility."
“Most people know that laxatives are abused by teenagers — girls talk about it in school, it’s on the internet. Selling that amount is beyond words,” she told the coroner.
Dr Naso said that a letter should have been requested from the woman's doctor. "It is hard to not see this as a purely financial transaction that was of benefit to the owner," she said.
Reluctance to deny patient demands also emerged when she was admitted to hospital, weighing only 35 kilos. A CT scan showed dozens of tablets in her stomach. Nonetheless, she decided to leave the hospital nine days before her death. The doctor in charge advised against it but was reluctant to press the issue because she did not appear to have a mental illness.
The psychiatrist questioned the doctor’s judgement. "She was willing to place herself at risk and leave her daughter potentially motherless — this itself should have raised grave concerns for her mental state." Other doctors had raised the possibility of anorexia nervosa. The doctor could have legally required her to remain in hospital for 24 hours in order to get a psychiatric assessment.
It appears that too many people, including her family, said Yes to Mrs La Bella. Now she is dead.
This article is published by
and BioEdge under a Creative Commons licence. You may republish it or translate it free of charge with attribution for non-commercial purposes following these guidelines
. If you teach at a university we ask that your department make a donation. Commercial media must contact us
for permission and fees. Some articles on this site are published under different terms.