How can we solve the shortage of organ donors?
Clearly there’s no easy answer. But two bioethicists have a very practical suggestion: why not provide more detailed information to potential donors about those who need an organ transplant?
Writing in the Journal of Medical Ethics, David Shaw (University of Basel) and Dale Gardiner (Nottingham University NHS Trust) argue that providing real-life stories of the benefits of organ donation could greatly increase the likelihood of donation; the researchers propose that a detailed leaflet be given to patients and families who are making decisions about organ donation. This would help to overcome the moral distance between donors and recipients, and increase an awareness of the variety of benefits that organ donation yields:
“Providing more detailed information about recipients...may increase the consent rate by helping to reduce [the] moral distance from those who might benefit from donation...This information could include a description of what it is like to wait for an organ, how donation benefitted them and also stories from families of those who donated. Providing this information could also help heighten awareness among staff of the importance of donation. We would not propose providing details of the actual recipients of organs from a given patient, but instead providing a representative sample of those who could benefit, or have benefited.”
Shaw and Gardiner are not unaware of the risks of coercion that come with providing emotive information to patients and families; these individuals are already in a distressed state and may feel pressured by information that implies an obligation to donate. Yet the authors suggest that generic exemplar cases would not induce distress as much as details of people currently on the waiting-list would.
This article is published by
and BioEdge under a Creative Commons licence. You may republish it or translate it free of charge with attribution for non-commercial purposes following these guidelines
. If you teach at a university we ask that your department make a donation. Commercial media must contact us
for permission and fees. Some articles on this site are published under different terms.