Landmark UK decision broadens scope of surrogacy


In a landmark decision, the High Court in the UK has ruled that it is discriminatory to prevent single men or women from becoming the parents of babies born to surrogate mothers. The government will probably have to update its legislation to make it compatible with the ruling.

Until now, only couples in a stable relationship could become parents of a child born to a surrogate mother. Single people could adopt children, but they were not automatically entitled to be regarded as a parent if their child was born to a surrogate.

In this case an unnamed man used his sperm, a donor egg and a surrogate mother in Minnesota to create a child, who is called “Z” in court documents. But when he brought the baby back to the UK, he was not regarded as a parent, but rather the surrogate mother. (Ironically, in the US, the surrogate mother has no legal status.) So Z was made a ward of the court, with custody awarded to his father, a situation which will now change.

The solicitor for Z’s father, Natalie Gamble, commented: “The UK has a proud tradition of taking a progressive approach to assisted reproduction and non-traditional families, and the current surrogacy laws are a glaring anomaly which fail to uphold our most fundamental values of safeguarding children's welfare.”

The government did not contest Z’s father’s case and admitted to the court that the law had breached human rights legislation, was discriminatory against single parents and needed to be changed.

The decision was severely criticised by people who interpreted it as an attack on the traditional family. A Labour MP and former Minister Frank Field told The Mail on Sunday: “In all these decisions, the natural rights of children get overlooked. Parenting is a huge job and it’s about time that children are put centre stage, not selfish adults.”

Family policy analyst Jill Kirby commented: “This judgment undermines the traditional family and the child’s needs – the evidence shows that children will thrive much better with two parents caring for them. The Government seems to have abandoned the idea of promoting stronger families.”




MORE ON THESE TOPICS | surrogacy, UK

This article is published by Michael Cook and BioEdge under a Creative Commons licence. You may republish it or translate it free of charge with attribution for non-commercial purposes following these guidelines. If you teach at a university we ask that your department make a donation. Commercial media must contact us for permission and fees. Some articles on this site are published under different terms.

 
 Search BioEdge

 Subscribe to BioEdge newsletter
rss Subscribe to BioEdge RSS feed

 
comments powered by Disqus