British boy cured with cells from “saviour sibling”

UK doctors say that a six-year-old boy has been cured of a rare blood disorder because of transplants from a baby brother who was created to give him tissue-matched healthy blood cells. Charlie Whitaker was born with Diamond Blackfan anaemia, which is normally a fatal condition. His parents failed to get permission from British authorities to create a "saviour sibling", so they sought help from a Chicago clinic which offered pre-implantation genetic diagnosis. A baby brother was born last year.

Ethicist John Harris, of the University of Manchester, denied that Charlie's case was a step towards designer babies or creating babies for spare parts. "What better reason could there conceivably be for having a child than to save the life of an existing person? There is no better reason," he declared. Opponents of the treatment countered that "you are using that child as a means to an end, rather than as an end in itself," in the words of Dr David King, of Human Genetics Alert.


 Search BioEdge

 Subscribe to BioEdge newsletter
rss Subscribe to BioEdge RSS feed

comments powered by Disqus