April
20
  9:59:38 PM

More restraint was needed in reporting Savita’s death

tags:

Hi there,

One of the impressive things about the reaction of the police and the government in Boston after the terrible bomb blasts near the marathon finishing line was restraint. The authorities dampened speculation about who was responsible for the atrocity. It could have been a lone lunatic, or a right-wing militia group. Even the media waited until the facts were in. As it turns out the two suspects, one alive and one dead, are Chechen Muslims. But there was no feverish speculation, no finger-pointing, no lynch mobs.

Would that the world media had acted the same way when it covered the death of a 31-year-old dentist in Galway last November. Savita Halappanavar died of septic shock when she was 17 weeks pregnant. As her condition worsened, she asked for an abortion, but her fetus was still alive and her condition seemed manageable, so the doctors refused. Abortion is illegal in Ireland except to save the mother’s life.

The media whipped itself into a frenzy. “Ireland's law and Catholic culture allowed Savita Halappanavar to die,” was the headline in the New Statesman. There were demonstrations in London, Brussels, Berlin and India. Her death was blamed on the Catholic Church and restrictive abortion laws. There could not have been a newspaper in the world that did not carry the story.

But this week the official inquest handed down its verdict. In a unanimous decision, the jury blamed “medical misadventure”. A series of mishaps led to Savita’s death, but at the time, they nearly all seemed like reasonable decisions. It was not a story of stony-hearted prejudice and religious bias. But I don’t think that we will see many of the newspaper columnists apologising. In fact, few newspapers have even reported the story. 

In any case, legalising abortion might not help women like Savita at all. Despite -- or perhaps because of-- Ireland's ban, its maternal death rate (6 per 100,000) is one of the lowest in the world, lower, in fact, than countries where it is freely available, like Australia (7), England (12), New Zealand (15), or the United States (21).

Cheers,



comments powered by Disqus
 

 Search BioEdge

 Subscribe to BioEdge newsletter
get posts by email or
rss Subscribe to BioEdge RSS feed

 Recent Posts
The bioethical challenges of 2015
23 Nov 2014
A mystical side to suicide
15 Nov 2014
Nick Tonti-Filippini RIP
9 Nov 2014
Brittany Maynard changes her mind
2 Nov 2014
What you think of BioEdge
23 Oct 2014

 Best of the web

 Tags
donor anonymity, Alzheimer's disease, utilitarianism, music, Compassion & Choices, professional standards, Switzerland, human rights, Roman Empire, Augustus, Philip Nitschke, robotics, egg freezing, professional integrity, dementia, commercialization, IVF, soccer, bioethics, Baby Gammy, bioethicists, USA, Nobel Peace Prize, Belgium, surrogacy, euthanasia, ageing population, assisted suicide, Thailand, female genital mutilation,