12:18:56 AM

Leading bioethics journal runs article defending female genital mutilation


Hi there, 

There are stories which are so controversial that an editor hesitates before hitting the OK button. One such is the report below on female genital mutilation (FGM). One of the world’s leading bioethics journals, The Hastings Center Report, has published an article which claims that this practice – absolutely abhorrent to Westerners – has been badly misrepresented.

(Having reported this much, I noticed that a couple of Twitter followers immediately unfollowed us, so please grit your teeth and bear with me if you are feeling queasy or outraged.)

The authors of the report do not take a stand on whether FGM should be allowed to continue, but they do say that there is little evidence for sensational media claims.

Even an obstetrician-gynecologist at the Brigham and Women's Hospital in Boston, who is critical of FGM comments, “Speaking as both an African woman and an obstetrician-gynecologist, I hope that this practice ends during my lifetime. However, the impetus to abandon female genital cutting must come from within each community; a ban on it cannot be imposed by outsiders”. 

In view of the fact that the UN General Assembly is set to pass a non-binding resolution drafted by its human rights committee condemning FGM later this month, this is essential reading.

Cheers and thanks for your patience last week while I was away on holidays. 

comments powered by Disqus

 Search BioEdge

 Subscribe to BioEdge newsletter
get posts by email or
rss Subscribe to BioEdge RSS feed

 Recent Posts
The bioethical challenges of 2015
23 Nov 2014
A mystical side to suicide
15 Nov 2014
Nick Tonti-Filippini RIP
9 Nov 2014
Brittany Maynard changes her mind
2 Nov 2014
What you think of BioEdge
23 Oct 2014

 Best of the web

Thailand, Alzheimer's disease, donor anonymity, soccer, music, USA, Baby Gammy, Roman Empire, Philip Nitschke, female genital mutilation, ageing population, surrogacy, commercialization, robotics, egg freezing, human rights, euthanasia, professional standards, bioethicists, utilitarianism, Switzerland, dementia, Belgium, IVF, professional integrity, Nobel Peace Prize, Compassion & Choices, Augustus, assisted suicide, bioethics,