May
12
  10:50:10 PM

The all-too-human failings of scientists

tags:

Hi there, 

The novelist Sinclair Lewis is little read nowadays, even though he was the first American to win a Nobel Prize for literature. From what I can recall, he was hardly a great stylist, but he did have a knack of being at one and the same time a snooty critic of and naïve enthusiast for the Zeitgeist. In one of his novels, Arrowsmith, an old German professor gives a paean to scientists as the only true seekers after truth:

“The normal man, he does not care much what he does except that he should eat and sleep and make love.  But the scientist is intensely religious--he is so religious that he will not accept quarter-truths, because they are an insult to his faith. He wants that everything should be subject to inexorable laws… He is the only real revolutionary, the authentic scientist, because he alone knows how liddle he knows.”

Much of that respect lingers on. Thundering “The Science Has Spoken” is a common way of cutting off debate on public policy issues like evolution in schools, climate change and stem cell research. However, unknown to Sinclair Lewis’s epigones, many thoughtful scientists are worried about the progress of science. Even though the scientific method is universally accepted as one of mankind’s greatest achievements, it has been bruised by the all-too-human failings of scientists themselves: greed, aggression, fraud, and so on.

This week we report on alarm bells being rung in the scientific establishment. The implications for bioethical debates are pretty obvious. We should bow to science but we need not kowtow when research seems to support unethical behaviour.

On another front, we recently launched our fund-raising campaign. Please consider supporting the work of BioEdge.

Cheers,



comments powered by Disqus
 

 Search BioEdge

 Subscribe to BioEdge newsletter
get posts by email or
rss Subscribe to BioEdge RSS feed

 Recent Posts
The year draws to a close
20 Dec 2014
US report on CIA torture
14 Dec 2014
Lessons from Peru
6 Dec 2014
Looking for long-lost uncles
30 Nov 2014
The bioethical challenges of 2015
23 Nov 2014

 Best of the web

 Tags
surrogacy, dementia, music, USA, Thailand, egg freezing, commercialization, donor anonymity, euthanasia, Alzheimer's disease, IVF, bioethics, Switzerland, Australia, professional integrity, population control, utilitarianism, Compassion & Choices, genetic parentage, Philip Nitschke, permanent vegetative state, Belgium, genetic orphans, human rights, professional standards, female genital mutilation, ageing population, assisted suicide, Peru, films,