June
24
  5:28:00 PM

New Zealand committee recommends sex selection

New Zealanders should have access to sex selection through IVF, the New Zealand Bioethics Council (or Toi Te Taiao in the Maori language) has recommended. "We have not heard sufficient cultural, ethical or spiritual concerns to justify banning it — providing PGD [prenatal genetic diagnosis] is undertaken at the parents’ own cost," says the "Who Gets Born" report.

However, the council does believe that the public’s puzzling opposition to sex selection warrants further investigation, as the idea seemed relatively innocuous to its members. "Perhaps [these concerns] stem from a perception that this is a comparatively trivial application for a technology with profound implications, or they may be related to distaste for practices in some countries where girl babies are routinely aborted or abandoned in favour of boys." The council also recommended that parents be enabled to create "saviour siblings" for sick children. At the moment, this is very restricted in New Zealand.

The discussion of bioethical issues in New Zealand has a dimension which is lacking elsewhere. European – mostly British -- stock (pakeha, in Maori) and their culture dominate the country. It is as secular and socially progressive as Britain, Australia, or most Western European countries. However, for historical and legal reasons, all government decision-making has to take into account the cultural values of the indigenous Maori people who tend to be far more sceptical of liberal theories of autonomy and individual rights and more alert to their genetic inheritance. Hence, Who Gets Born" reports candidly that Maoris generally favour "the sanctity of human life" and take decisions collectively. Nonetheless, the council appears to sidestep this and uses pakeha reasoning to frame its proposal for government policy.




 

 Search BioEdge

 Subscribe to BioEdge newsletter
rss Subscribe to BioEdge RSS feed

 Best of the web

 Recent Posts
Indian surrogate for US woman dies in Gurjarat
18 May 2012
Do reproductive rights survive gender reassignment?
19 May 2012
South African activists begin euthanasia campaign
19 May 2012
70 assisted suicides in Washington state in 2011
19 May 2012
Would-be grandparents pay for their daughters’ egg freezing
19 May 2012

 Tags
genetic testing, sex selection, UK, Netherlands, stem cells, Down syndrome, US, suicide, clinical trials, organ trafficking, China, India, organ donation, organ transplants, research, bioethics, neuroscience, embryonic stem cells, commercialization, abortion, assisted suicide, sperm donation, law, euthanasia, Australia, surrogacy, Canada, informed consent, human drama, IVF,