March
09
 

Bioethics, a profession plagued by doubts

With two Italian/Australian bioethicists under attack in the media around the globe over the moral permissibility of infanticide, there are signs of the collywobbles in the profession as a whole. Over at the Journal of Medical Ethics blog, Iain Brassington, presents as evidence an interview with a leading feminist bioethicist, Hilde Lindemann.

“A few years ago I was at a metaethics workshop, and over breakfast a male colleague and I made a game of ranking the different specialties in philosophy according to how prestigious they were - a ranking with a precise inverse correlation to gender. Here’s the list we came up with:

“* Philosophy of Mind, Philosophy of Language, and Metaphysics: The alpha-dominant philosophy, done by Real Men 
* Epistemology and Philosophy of Science: Done by manly enough men 
* Metaethics: Done by men who aren’t entirely secure in their masculinity 
* Ethics, Social and Political Philosophy: Done by girls 
* Bioethics: Done by stupid girls [italics added]
* Feminist philosophy, of course, is not philosophy at all.”

Dr Brassington agrees that “not enormously highly regarded as a discipline by philosophers”. But why? He advances five hypotheses: bioethicists get their hands dirty with the real world; conventional philosophers are jealous of the high media profile of some bioethicists; sub-standard philosophizing; bioethics is “just too weighed-down with all kinds of other stuff”; and anyone can call himself a bioethicist.

Unfortunately, he admits ruefully, “every so often, there is some utter dreck that surfaces” in academic conferences. Apparently there will be a robust discussion of the issue at the 2012 International Association of Bioethics in Rotterdam. 




 

 Search BioEdge

 Subscribe to BioEdge newsletter
rss Subscribe to BioEdge RSS feed

 Best of the web

 Recent Posts
Belgian intensive care doctors back involuntary euthanasia
11 Apr 2014
To freeze perchance to live
12 Apr 2014
British woman ‘weary of modern life’ euthanased in Switzerland
12 Apr 2014
The Lancet sounds alarm over care of the elderly
12 Apr 2014
Action needed on US doctors’ involvement in torture
12 Apr 2014

 Tags
human drama, China, neuroscience, Julian Savulescu, US, clinical trials, suicide, informed consent, organ trafficking, Australia, Netherlands, abortion, organ donation, UK, sperm donation, assisted suicide, enhancement, euthanasia, India, IVF, Belgium, genetic testing, Down syndrome, stem cells, surrogacy, commercialization, Switzerland, law, Canada, bioethics,