Australians debate commercial surrogacy

Australia should legalize commercial surrogacy to stop the exploitation of women overseas and to ensure that agreements are properly regulated to protect children, surrogates and commissioning parents, says the Chief Federal Court Magistrate John Pascoe.

Mr Pascoe argues that overseas surrogacy should remain banned – although this has failed to stop hundreds of Australian couples from engaging surrogates in India and elsewhere. The possibility of exploitation would be much less in Australia, he says. “We would know women here wouldn't be forced or threatened to carry a child and that they will be paid more than a few hundred dollars and receive proper medical care.”

The current situation in Australia is restrictive. Altruistic surrogacy is permitted but overseas commercial surrogacy has been criminalised in New South Wales, Queensland and the Australian Capital Territory. 

Even progressive ethicists are split on this contentious topic. Bioethicist Leslie Cannold strongly opposes commercial surrogacy. Even in Australia women could be exploited. “We should not create a situation in which we coerce people economically,” she told The Age. But Loane Skene, another prominent bioethicist, is confident that safeguards could be enshrined in law. “The best form of protection for [surrogates] and any children to be born from surrogacy may be legislation that enables commercial surrogacy to be undertaken openly, by trained, registered health professionals, in licensed and monitored premises.” It would also enable records of the child’s parentage to be maintained.

The Australian Attorney-General, Nicola Roxon, announced earlier this year that the Family Law Council, which evaluates how well the Family Law Act is working, would conduct a study of the impact of surrogacy. Its report is due in December next year.  

This article is published by Michael Cook and under a Creative Commons licence. You may republish it or translate it free of charge with attribution for non-commercial purposes following these guidelines. If you teach at a university we ask that your department make a donation. Commercial media must contact us for permission and fees. Some articles on this site are published under different terms.

comments powered by Disqus

 Search BioEdge

 Subscribe to BioEdge newsletter
rss Subscribe to BioEdge RSS feed

 Best of the web

 Recent Posts
Transplant doctors clash over Chinese organ donor system
20 Aug 2016
Baby boomers will clamour for euthanasia, says Udo Schuklenk
20 Aug 2016
More donating their bodies to science
20 Aug 2016
Bioethicist alleges “publication bias” at NEJM
20 Aug 2016
Australia urges Cambodia to crack down on surrogacy services
20 Aug 2016